|
After much listening I took time out to re assess the whole project.
Seemed to me
with Tri-Amping and changing the Tweeter to the Seas unit, I was
getting further and further from what was special about these speakers
so I put the original HF2000 tweeters back in. After taking the 66's to
a local bake off, the consensus of opinion was that the mid range
needed bringing forward as it was not strong enough. I swapped the
MF500 drivers for the later MD500's which I already had, as I knew
these were more forward sounding. I changed the x-over values to suit
both these driver changes as shown above and this did the trick.
Without doubt the best they have sounded. I used a mixture of caps for
the crucial 24uf in the mid range filter, approx 95% Mundorf ECap
(Plain) Bipolar electrolytic and 5% Ansar Supersound Polyprop. This
produced the right balance, the PP adding a bit of extra body without
the problems of using a total value of Polyprop. I'm very happy with
these now and the circuit/parts/layout I settled on can be seen in the
PDF file linked at 66_13.
Final Version
So after all the
experimenting I have ended up with capacitor values exactly as the
original ones that Celestion used and they have been replaced like for
like, that is to say, film caps replaced by film caps and electrolytics
replaced with electrolytics. This sounds excellent and better than all
the other versions I tried. Do not be tempted to replace everything
with polyprops, it just does not work and in my case sounded worse than
the old Elcaps.
The Brand of
film cap you use in the HF filter is important and I found Ansar
Supersound worked best over all. The critical 24uf series cap in the
mid range filter is also noticeably effected by the brand
used, Mundorf ECap worked best with about 5% Ansar Polyprop in the
mix as exsplained above.
That's me done on this project and I will now enjoy listening to these very nice speakers.
Completed May 2015
|